McMaster key in quick turnaround of care guidelines for COVID-19 patients in ICU
Waleed Alhazzani is an associate professor of medicine at McMaster University. Photo by Georgia Kirkos
BY Tina Depko, Health Sciences
April 1, 2020
An international team including McMaster University researchers has come together to issue guidelines for health-care workers treating intensive care unit (ICU) patients with COVID-19.
The Surviving Sepsis Campaign COVID-19 panel has released 54 recommendations on such topics as infection control, laboratory diagnosis and specimens, the dynamics of blood flow support, ventilation support, and COVID-19 therapy.
The panel of 36 experts, with seven from McMaster, telescoped what would have been more than a year of work into less than three weeks.
The guidelines were co-published in the journals Critical Care Medicine and Intensive Care Medicine.
“Previously there was limited guidance on acute management of critically ill patients with COVID-19, although the World Health Organization and the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have issued preliminary guidance on infection control, screening and diagnosis in the general population,” said first author Waleed Alhazzani, associate professor of medicine at McMaster. He is also an intensive care physician at St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton.
“Usually, it takes a year or two to develop large clinical practice guidelines such as these ones. Given the urgency and the huge need for these guidelines, we assembled the team, searched the literature, summarized the evidence, and formulated recommendations within 18 days. Everyone worked hard to make this guideline available to the end user rapidly while maintaining methodological rigour.”
Alhazzani added that the guidelines will be used by frontline clinicians, allied health professionals and policy makers involved in the care of patients with COVID-19.
The Surviving Sepsis Campaign COVID-19 panel included experts in guideline development, infection control, infectious diseases and microbiology, critical care, emergency medicine, nursing, and public health.
McMaster faculty members of the panel included Alhazzani; Mark Loeb, professor of pathology and molecular medicine; Simon Oczkowski, assistant professor of medicine; Emilie Belley-Côté, assistant professor of medicine; Paul E. Alexander, assistant professor of health research methods, evidence, and impact; John Centofanti, assistant professor of anesthesia; and Bandar Baw, associate professor of medicine.
The corresponding author of the guidelines is Andrew Rhodes of St. George’s Healthcare NHS Trust in the United Kingdom.
Others on the panel came from Australia, Canada, China, Denmark, Italy, Korea, the Netherlands, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom, United States and Saudi Arabia.
The panel started off by proposing 53 questions they considered to be relevant to the management of COVID-19 in the intensive care unit (ICU). The team then searched the literature for direct and indirect evidence on the management of COVID-19 in the ICU. They found relevant and recent systematic reviews on most questions relating to supportive care.
The group then assessed the certainty in the evidence using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach, which itself was developed at McMaster. GRADE is a way to assess previous work, a transparent framework for developing and presenting summaries of evidence and provides a systematic approach for making clinical practice recommendations for health-care professionals.
The Guideline in Intensive Care Development and Evaluation (GUIDE) group, a Hamilton-based scientific group that is chaired by Alhazzani and Belley-Côté, ensured the approach to creating the guidelines was sound.
The resulting 54 recommendations include four best practice statements, nine strong recommendations, and 35 weak recommendations. No recommendation was provided for six questions. The four best practice statements based on high-quality evidence include:
- Health-care workers performing aerosol-generating procedures, such as intubation, bronchoscopy, open suctioning, on patients with COVID-19 should wear fitted respirator masks, such as N95, FFP2 or equivalent – instead of surgical masks – in addition to other personal protective equipment, such as gloves, gown and eye protection.
- Aerosol-generating procedures should be performed on ICU patients with COVID-19 in a negative pressure room, if available. Negative pressure rooms are engineered to prevent the spread of contagious pathogens from room to room.
- Endotracheal intubation of patients with COVID-19 should be performed by health-care workers with experience in airway management to minimize the number of attempts and risk of transmission.
- Adults with COVID-19 who are being treated with non-invasive positive pressure ventilation or a high flow nasal cannula should be closely monitored for worsening respiratory status and intubated early if needed.
Jonathan Bramson, vice-dean of research for the Faculty of Health Sciences, said: “This will have a tremendous impact, right now and worldwide, on how the most serious patients with COVID-19 are treated.”
The Surviving Sepsis Campaign COVID-19 panel said it plans to issue further guidelines in order to update the recommendations, if needed, or formulate new ones.
There was no dedicated funding for the guidelines.